Tuesday, October 04, 2005
Seeking The 3rd Alternative

 

Diversity in viewpoints is almost a fact of life in the world, in evangelicalism, in the church – how can we actively build on this fact, instead of being shy, apprehensive or quiet about it? 
 
In CHURCH, we may think of asking people what their various views are on various position, in order to encourage:

  • Respect, listening and learning among members (esp of the same congregation)
  • Sharper focus on the variation in perspectives depending on:
    • Age-group (what can senior citizens learn from Linkin' Parkin' teenagers?!)
    • Gender (to foster greater understanding between the sexes on issues which pertain to both? Maybe we could compare the Sisters' Fellowship feelings/readings of the Passion narratives with that of the Football team's?)
    • Profession (what can an accountant 'see' in the book of Colossians that a chemical engineer can't?)
    • Nationalities (quite popular already, but it's sometimes ironic to see greater understanding/interaction between an Aussie and a Malaysian, than between that same Malaysian and, say, his classmate in college!)
  • Greater patience and unity in spite of the differences
  • Less arrogance and divisiveness over what is often misunderstood, misrepresented and unimportant

As THEOLOGIANS, the patient and careful appreciation and learning from various views allows us to :

  • Detect and genuinely admit weaknesses in our own position
  • See useful and meaningful connections between the different views
  • Seek BETTER ALTERNATIVES than all the options presented(!) This usually requires:
    • Restating an opposing view to the satisfaction of their leading proponents
    • Deep and genuine empathy for another's position
  • See previously 'missed' strengths and benefits in opposing positions (which we may incorporate into our own, or seek to benefit from)
  • Juxtapose or integrate multiple (perhaps even mutually exclusive) positions? This is in contrast to taking a "X is right, Y and Z are wrong" stance.
    • E.g. Clark Pinnock, in 4 Views of Hell, was unique in his response to Zachary Hayes' Purgatorial view of hell, by suggesting an Evangelical revision of this perspective. Instead of merely pointing out points of disagreement and agreement, he went a step further in attempting to improve his own position using some elements Hayes' presentation, thereby also strengthening his rapport with Hayes (This is not to say that I endorse Pinnock's eventual view of hell entirely; it's the method of constructing something positive from an opponent's arguments that I wish to highlight here. Needless to say, I don't think a perspective focused primarily on criticism will pay attention to such opportunities)
  • Learn about how different cultures respond to, interpret, express a certain doctrinal issue (or Scriptural passage) e.g.: Post-Colonialism? Diaspora attitudes? Third-World theologies?

As INDIVIDUALS, the 'many views' pseudo-paradigm can help us to fairness and humility by:

  • Seeking first to understand before expressing scepticism/criticism
  • Seeing God in even those who hold drastically opposite views from us (which reminds us, yet again, that often it's more important to show our love than to prove our correctness)

Posted at 07:39 am by alwynlau

Posted by Alwyn @ 10/09/2005 05:08 PM PDT
It's lacking even in myself, sigh... which is why you *could* say I'm hoping pomo helps many of us turn a new leaf...thanks for the comment, :)
Posted by soo tian @ 10/07/2005 11:26 PM PDT
"Seeing God in even those who hold drastically opposite views from us (which reminds us, yet again, that often it’s more important to show our love than to prove our correctness)" This IMO is really lacking among most Christians I know.. ;)
 

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments







Previous Entry Home Next Entry



Amor, Ergo Sum
"I Am Loved, Therefore I Am"





God-Talk

God's Glory Rethought
Pre-Apologetics
Parable of the Computer
Quiet Revolution of Hope (Friends in Conversation)
If God Already Knows, Why Pray?
Faith of the Centurion (Luke 7)
China Wine / Geisha Video
Theology for Migrant Workers?
ROH & People's Theology
God in the Center
Emergent: Faith & Politics
Explaining Trinity
Jesus' Wilderness Temptation
Divine Foreknowledge Quiz
Theology as Comedy?
Already / Not Yet
First Gay Church Malaysia
Why Doesn't God Heal All?
Truth & Thinking
Explaining Atonement
Kierkegaard's Willing/Waiting
Psalm 16: A Meditation
Radical Orthopraxy
Spiritual Formation
Freewill & Causality
Top 5 Apologetics Questions
Emergent's Detractors
Tithing
Burnout Pastors
Ravi Zacharias
Simplicity & Paris Hilton
Body of God
4 Views of Jesus
God of the Casual
3 Umpires
Responding to Flak
Eastern Orthodoxy
Theology's Point-Missing
Post-Colonial Church?
Models of God
Baptism
On Prayer
"If God Knew Adam & Eve Would Sin..."
Inerrancy: Emergent, Not Assumed
Colour Bursts
LQPM
EMO 4 All
PostModernism in Practice
Fast & Fun
7
Escaping the Matrix
Rocking Helm's Deep
The Intelligence Trap
Changing States
Truth as Dialogue
Post-Modern Atonement?
False Constructs
More Derridean Than We Think
Top 46
Crossan & Derrida


Page/Screen/Tunes

Dead Poets' Society Quote
GhostWritten, David Mitchell
Emergent Manifesto of Hope
Wild Swans, Jung chang
Ratatouille Quote
Faith of the Outsider, Frank Spina
What is a Movie?
Mangoes & Bananas, Hwa Yung
Thomas Heatherwick
Openness of God, Pinnock et al
Church in Emerging Culture (5 Views)
Atonement, Ian McEwan
Stories of Emergence
Birdsong, Sebastian Faulks
Who's Afraid of PostModernism? JKA Smith
Lorenzo's Song
Polonius' Homily
Family Man
Erring (Mark C. Taylor)
Sunetra Gupta
Angelina Jolie & Jeffrey Sachs
Collapse (Jared Diamond)
Sin City
Stephen King/Hunter
Nigger
Da Vinci
Number9 Dream
V 4 Vendetta
Freedomland
Capote
HERO
Movie Madness
Meme (Books)
Book Updates
No Logo, N.Klein
Philosophical Confessions, B.Magee
Kafka On the Shore, H.Murakami
Dan Brown's Betters


Everything Else











Blogs



Contact Me

If you want to be updated on this weblog Enter your email here:





 Subscribe in a reader