Sunday, May 21, 2006
Four Portraits, One Lord

Saturday's EMO meeting started with Kia Meng taking the platform to lead the worship. I haven't heard him sing and play the guitar since college days - I'm sure I'm not the only one who thinks that all of us haven't heard him lead worship enough. Period (smile).

Then came our four views of Jesus.

Collin presented his conviction (heavily resonant with Roman Catholic teaching) that an encounter with Jesus begins with the Eucharist / Holy Communion. In this sacrament of grace we partake of and be joined in remembrance with Jesus the bread of life, Jesus the bread for the poor, Jesus the bread for others, Jesus the wine of His saving blood. The Eucharist is a constant celebration and a proclamation of the gospel, a sending forth in service and love to the outcasts and marginalised.

It was quite extraordinary to witness the abundance and richness of practical other-centered theology flowing out from the meal our Lord gave us. How we need to listen more carefully to what Jesus' Roman Catholic disciples can teach us.

David's address was a welcomed reminder of the key tenets of evangelicalism and its portrait of Jesus, also my own tradition ever since I can remember. His ten minutes or so could've passed as a summary of just about every sermon I've heard (and/or paid attention to!) in the past 15 years. Jesus is worshipped as a grace-giving Lord and Saviour, He is either Lord of all or not at all, an understanding not only in continuity with history but also generative of deep intimacy with Christ. The Jesus of our faith encompasses both the sacred and secular and resists/transcends our attempts at compartmentalisation.

I laughed at David's take on the popular evangelically-inspired "hierarchy" of professions (from the most respectable to the least), beginning with Missionary, then Pastor, following by Full-Time Worker all the way down to Lawyer and Jazz Musician! We were also told that among evangelicalism's ugliest sides was the use of social action (and even personal friendships, I might add) as a means of evangelism, in addition to an over-emphasis on an overly private faith perhaps tempting the evangelical to leave one's convictions publicly irrelevant.

(Speaking from within this tradition too, I'd like to add the little nuance that maybe it's an individualistic faith that we must guard against even as we seek to grow in [private] intimacy with our loving Father. Maybe evangelical Christians require a more community-oriented praxis and theology.)

This was the first time I've heard David speak and I must say I appreciated the short hour-plus of warm-hearted sharing, honest challenging and (of course!) hearty laughter (*big grin!*).

Pastor Raj (who replaced Pastor Luke, who couldn't make it) then gave us a snapshot of his experience pastoring a Pentecostal congregation. He noted how he would like to see more Charismatic leaders and churches talk about the humanity and suffering of Jesus, to complement their emphasis on His power, victory and gifts in/of the Spirit, especially speaking in tongues. He also alluded to an extreme form of AOG-ism in which the sick are told that their healing is guaranteed, failing which the fault must lie with them.

Nevertheless, the experiential, viscerally impacting and ultimately life-changing dunamis of the Holy Spirit is something our Pentecostal brothers and sisters are leading the way in. We would look to them for more learning of and partaking in this power.

I then took the soapbox in a rather rough tumble of a summary of N.T. Wright's historical/eschatological Jesus (I can barely imagine how Wright would feel if he could hear what I half-shouted in a mega-hurried manner). How do you condense an ocean into a pond? I'm making it worse by summarising my summary(!), but for what it's worth:

Wright portrays Jesus as a prophet who believed that he was embodying and bringing in the kingdom of God which connotes the victory of God over His (and by extension, Israel's) enemies, the return from exile of Israel and the forgiveness of her sins. He attacked Israel's cherished symbols (Temple, Sabbath, Land, Family, etc.) and sought to replace them with redefined ones. He wanted to reconstitute Israel, invite people to be part of the "new Israel" with new badges of God's people (cf. the Sermon on the Mount), a new praxis. Jesus went to the Cross, then, as the ultimate act of God's judgment on Israel's enemies, Israel herself and His triumph against suffering via suffering. The Resurrection was God's vindication of Jesus and the confirmation that God's new world has come, a new dawn was breaking through the darkness.

We, as God's true humanity, are then called to reflect the glory of Jesus by 1) telling the story of Jesus, 2) challenging the ways and symbols of false humanity and 3) subversively and lovingly issuing a counter-empire declaration to the world that "Jesus is Lord!". That is what the Gospel means.

Sivin then closed us with a worship celebration of the Lord's Supper, a fitting (and embodied!) ending to the meeting, a worship service with a difference.

And maybe that was the best point of all: That our theologies and our perspectives find harmony, meaning and validity in our worship and coming together as a people, as a family.

So when's the post-modern Jesus making His appearance?

Posted at 10:58 pm by alwynlau

Posted by Alwyn @ 09/21/2007 08:53 PM PDT
hi SS, good to meet yr acquaintance...so you're new to blogging? of course we can chat...i'm not an RC, exactly the opposite: I'm a Lutheran(!), at least in 'church' name. my theology has, however, 'evolved' to a point where I doubt Dr. Luther himself would be happy wif me, ;>)

and you are ----?
Posted by sandsweet @ 09/21/2007 05:45 PM PDT
Hi Alwyn.... I am inviting you to read my blog... hope you like it and perhaps we can share our faith and testimonies.. and opinions... Are you a Roman Catholic? I have a lot to talk on that .... can we??
Posted by Alwyn @ 05/25/2006 09:00 AM PDT
Patrick ~ thanks 4 visiting! i enjoy your blog too, esp with its postmodern motifs (I even shared one of your posts, "Deconstructing Theology" methinks, with some of my pals here

Jack ~ in fact Wright *is* generally known to be evangelical too, except he has no qualms jettisoning elements of it which he finds unhistorical. i get a feeling he won't be overly concerned about being labeled non-evangelical if push comes to shove
Posted by Jack @ 05/24/2006 07:36 PM PDT
Aiya, missed! But well, better for me I guess, or else I will have trouble choosing sides....if I really had to. ;)

"Wright not evangelical meh?" When I first saw the list of presenters and their titles.
Posted by Patrick @ 05/23/2006 11:32 PM PDT
Alwyn,

You have some really nice posts on this blog...thanks!

I recently read N.T. Wright's "The Challenge of Jesus" and enjoyed it very much. Your summary was good and to-the-point. Brian McLaren's latest book, "The Secret Message of Jesus" is heavily influenced by Wright.

Blessings!
Patrick
 

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments







Previous Entry Home Next Entry



Amor, Ergo Sum
"I Am Loved, Therefore I Am"





God-Talk

God's Glory Rethought
Pre-Apologetics
Parable of the Computer
Quiet Revolution of Hope (Friends in Conversation)
If God Already Knows, Why Pray?
Faith of the Centurion (Luke 7)
China Wine / Geisha Video
Theology for Migrant Workers?
ROH & People's Theology
God in the Center
Emergent: Faith & Politics
Explaining Trinity
Jesus' Wilderness Temptation
Divine Foreknowledge Quiz
Theology as Comedy?
Already / Not Yet
First Gay Church Malaysia
Why Doesn't God Heal All?
Truth & Thinking
Explaining Atonement
Kierkegaard's Willing/Waiting
Psalm 16: A Meditation
Radical Orthopraxy
Spiritual Formation
Freewill & Causality
Top 5 Apologetics Questions
Emergent's Detractors
Tithing
Burnout Pastors
Ravi Zacharias
Simplicity & Paris Hilton
Body of God
4 Views of Jesus
God of the Casual
3 Umpires
Responding to Flak
Eastern Orthodoxy
Theology's Point-Missing
Post-Colonial Church?
Models of God
Baptism
On Prayer
"If God Knew Adam & Eve Would Sin..."
Inerrancy: Emergent, Not Assumed
Colour Bursts
LQPM
EMO 4 All
PostModernism in Practice
Fast & Fun
7
Escaping the Matrix
Rocking Helm's Deep
The Intelligence Trap
Changing States
Truth as Dialogue
Post-Modern Atonement?
False Constructs
More Derridean Than We Think
Top 46
Crossan & Derrida


Page/Screen/Tunes

Dead Poets' Society Quote
GhostWritten, David Mitchell
Emergent Manifesto of Hope
Wild Swans, Jung chang
Ratatouille Quote
Faith of the Outsider, Frank Spina
What is a Movie?
Mangoes & Bananas, Hwa Yung
Thomas Heatherwick
Openness of God, Pinnock et al
Church in Emerging Culture (5 Views)
Atonement, Ian McEwan
Stories of Emergence
Birdsong, Sebastian Faulks
Who's Afraid of PostModernism? JKA Smith
Lorenzo's Song
Polonius' Homily
Family Man
Erring (Mark C. Taylor)
Sunetra Gupta
Angelina Jolie & Jeffrey Sachs
Collapse (Jared Diamond)
Sin City
Stephen King/Hunter
Nigger
Da Vinci
Number9 Dream
V 4 Vendetta
Freedomland
Capote
HERO
Movie Madness
Meme (Books)
Book Updates
No Logo, N.Klein
Philosophical Confessions, B.Magee
Kafka On the Shore, H.Murakami
Dan Brown's Betters


Everything Else











Blogs



Contact Me

If you want to be updated on this weblog Enter your email here:





 Subscribe in a reader